Biweekly New Episode
Nov. 9, 2026

S4E19: Beyond Box-Ticking: What It Means to Be a Responsible Company with NYU Stern's Alison Taylor

S4E19: Beyond Box-Ticking: What It Means to Be a Responsible Company with NYU Stern's Alison Taylor
S4E19: Beyond Box-Ticking: What It Means to Be a Responsible Company with NYU Stern's Alison Taylor
Sustainability Forward
S4E19: Beyond Box-Ticking: What It Means to Be a Responsible Company with NYU Stern's Alison Taylor

In this episode of Sustainability Forward, Alison Taylor, Clinical Associate Professor at NYU Stern School of Business and author of Higher Ground, joins us to examine what responsible business really looks like when sustainability becomes harder, more political and more commercially demanding.

Alison argues that companies need to move beyond box-ticking, broad ESG scorecards and public commitments spread across too many issues. Instead, they should go “narrow and deep”, focusing on a small number of genuinely material priorities where they have both legitimacy and leverage.

The discussion explores why reversing commitments has damaged trust, why sustainability must be embedded across functions such as procurement, operations, finance and government affairs, and how companies can avoid saying one thing publicly while doing another internally.

The conversation also covers the growing role of employees in holding companies accountable, including Alison’s observation that “leaking is the new whistleblowing”, and why younger employees are increasingly willing to expose inconsistencies between corporate messaging and internal behaviour.

Alison closes by reflecting on how leaders can find a credible path between two extremes: doing nothing beyond shareholder value, and trying to solve every social and environmental problem at once.

At its core, the episode is about moving sustainability from reporting to strategy, and rebuilding trust through focus, consistency and honest decision-making.

What if the biggest risk to corporate sustainability isn't the backlash against it, but the habit of treating it as a reporting exercise rather than a strategic one?

In this episode of Sustainability Forward, we are joined by Alison Taylor, Clinical Associate Professor at NYU Stern School of Business, former Executive Director of Ethical Systems and author of Higher Ground: How Business Can Do the Right Thing in a Turbulent World. Drawing on two decades advising multinational companies, including senior roles at BSR and Control Risks, Alison explains what is really happening to sustainability inside companies today. We explore why companies should go narrow and deep rather than tick boxes on dozens of issues, why reversed commitments have deepened public mistrust, and how leaders can find a credible path through polarised expectations.

What You'll Discover

- Narrow and Deep Beats Box-Ticking: Why picking fewer than five highly material issues, where a company has both legitimacy and leverage, builds more credibility than ESG commitments spread across 40 topics.

- Joined-Up Responsibility: How sustainability goals fall apart when government relations teams lobby against them or procurement teams squeeze the same suppliers that auditors are inspecting, and why transparency about failure builds more trust than glib over-promising.

- Strategic Leaking and the New Accountability: Why "leaking is the new whistleblowing", how younger employees are weaponising transparency, and why companies need consistent principles on when, and on what basis, to take a public position.

Building a responsible business requires more than a strong score or a polished disclosure. By deciding what they genuinely stand for, and what they are prepared to do when those choices carry a real cost, companies can rebuild the trust that box-ticking has eroded.

Alison Taylor Profile Photo

Clinical Associate Professor at NYU Stern School of Business

Alison Taylor is a clinical associate professor at NYU Stern School of Business, and the former executive director at Ethical Systems. Her previous work experience also includes being a Managing Director at non-profit business network BSR and a Senior Managing Director at Control Risks. She holds sustainability advisory roles at KKR and Unilever, and advises many other firms on strategic integrity challenges. She has expertise in strategy, sustainability, political and social risk, culture and behavior, human rights, ethics and compliance, and stakeholder engagement. Her book Higher Ground: How Business Can do the Right Thing in a Turbulent World was published by Harvard Business Review Press in February 2024, and won the 2024 Porchlight Award for best leadership and strategy book of the year. Alison received her Bachelor of Arts in Modern History from Balliol College, Oxford University, her MA in International Relations from the University of Chicago, and MA in Organizational Psychology from Columbia University.